Discover and Capital One are two of the best and most reliable financial services providers in the country. In a way, “Discover vs Capital One” is the kind of debate that is simply inevitable considering where these two financial giants have positioned themselves in the industry.
Of course, the choice between one or the other often comes down to simple issues such as personal preference. However, that doesn’t mean that there aren’t some objective factors that either make the two comparable or help one stand out over the other.
As such, the “Discover vs Capital One” debate is set to rage on and must be had for the sake of the neutrals and anyone who might be looking for card alternatives.
About the Two Financial Giants: Discover vs Capital One
If you are new to credit cards or are looking to get a new one, there’s a very good chance that you are going to come across at least four major brands (likely in this order):
- American Express
- Capital One
Discover and Capital One happen to be two of the largest credit card companies in the United States. Which one is bigger and better is an ongoing heated debate. According to The Nilson Report, Capital One might be slightly bigger than Discover in terms of credit cardholder purchases:
- Capital One credit cardholders typically spend about $336.91 billion a year
- Discover cardholders typically spend about $139.03 billion a year
Also notable is that Capital One has just over 60 million credit cardholders in the US, while Discover has just under that figure at around 57 million.
These numbers, however, don’t tell us much apart from the fact that both credit card brands are wildly popular, and their customers collectively spend billions of dollars every year.
But what about each card as individual entities?
Discover vs Capital One: Differences
As a company, Discover has a history of disruption as far as the credit card industry is concerned because it was one of the very first brands to offer customers no-fee credit cards. As things stand, the brand now has travel rewards, secured credit, and even cashback options.
On the other hand, Capital One is a highly reputable and widely known credit provider across the US. It has an impressive array of cash rewards, earning miles, and credit-building offers.
Here are some of the key differences between the two credit card brands:
While Capital One has physical branches in several states, including Washington, DC, New Jersey, Connecticut, Maryland, Louisiana, New York, Texas, Virginia, and Delaware, Discover does not.
Additionally, Capital One allows you to complete a select number of banking transactions at some of the few Capital One Cafés across the country. In contrast, Discover doesn’t have any physical locations across the US and prides itself on being an exclusively online financial service provider.
Since Capital One credit cards are typically backed by either Visa or MasterCard, they have a wider acceptance globally than Discover cards. This has been an ongoing issue, especially with Discover credit card clients who travel outside the US. The smartest move is to always have one or the other card as a backup plan.
Free Credit Score Checks
Both credit cards offer some version of free credit score checks. With your Discover card, you can use their free FICO Score service with the Discover Credit Scorecard. With Capital One credit cards, you can use the free VantageScore 3.0 offered in conjunction with CreditWise.
Even though most lenders prefer using the FICO score, both services can help you get your credit ranking and are available for all to use regardless of credit card membership.
Discover vs Capital One: Key Features Compared
Some similarities stand out for both cards. These include:
- Both cards require you to put down a security deposit
- Neither of the cards charges you an annual fee nor any foreign transaction fees
- Both cards can be offered to people who are trying to rebuild their credit, although approval isn’t necessarily guaranteed because there are income as well as other requirement thresholds to be met
Let’s take a closer look at these features side by side to try and determine which credit card is the best for you.
Credit Limit and Security Deposits
A secured card often requires you to put down a security deposit that is equal to the credit limit you want or for which you qualify. For example, if you are looking for a credit limit of $1,000, then your security deposit with be $1,000. The fundamentals are pretty much the same with the secured credit cards from both vendors except for some minor differences:
- Capital One Secured MasterCard: With this card, you can get a line of credit for the amount of money you deposit. However, those who qualify can deposit as little as $49 or $99 to get the minimum credit limit of $200. The thing about this is that you can keep increasing that credit limit by depositing more money even before you get the actual credit card. To make it even easier for those trying to rebuild their credit, you can make your deposits in $20 increments.
- Discover it Secured Credit Card: This option offers you a minimum deposit of $200 for a similar credit limit and a maximum deposit of $2,500 for a similar credit limit.
The Better Card: Capital One Secured MasterCard
In this instance, the Capital One Secured MasterCard is better than the Discover it Secured Credit Card for one single reason: tiny deposits. This is an extremely rare kind of credit card that allows new clients to deposit less than the minimum credit limit and still have access to that limit.
Also, it allows you to make deposits in small increments as you build up your credit limit. Since making these deposits can be difficult for people trying to rebuild their credit, having such options makes life much easier.
This is yet another thorny issue when it comes to choosing and using credit cards. Here’s how both brands stack up against each other on this front:
- Capital One Secured MasterCard: This card has a variable APR of 26.99%
- Discover it Secured Credit Card: This brand offers you an introductory APR of 10.99%. This applies to balance transfers for the first six months. Then it moves to a 22.99% variable APR.
The Better Card: Discover It Secured Credit Card
While both cards have a high ongoing interest rate, this is to be expected because these particular options are designed for people who have bad credit and are trying to rebuild it.
The Discover it Secured Credit Card is slightly better than the Capital One option since it offers a low introductory interest rate for the first six months and a lower ongoing variable APR. Any way you look at it, carrying debt on either of these cards wouldn’t be the best idea.
One of the biggest avenues for competition in the credit card industry is the kind of reward each brand offers to customers who regularly use their credit cards. Here’s how these two brands stack up against each other on that front:
- Capital One Secured MasterCard: No rewards
- Discover It Secured Credit Card: This is the one thing that sets this card apart from other secured credit card options on the market. For one thing, clients earn 2% of their cashback when they make everyday purchases at a restaurant or a gas station. This covers up to $1,000 spent every quarter. You also get 1% of your cashback on all other purchases. As a sign-up bonus, Discover has an offer to match all your cashback at the end of your first year as a new client. You don’t have to spend a specific minimum or maximum amount. They simply match you, dollar for dollar.
The Better Card: Discover It Secured Credit Card
When it comes to rewards, a Discover card is a much better option without question. Not only does it allow you to slowly build up your credit, but it also gives you some of your money back while you’re spending.
The Discover vs Capital One debate will rage on. This is especially true when you consider that both brands have a host of other credit cards that all have their competitive edges. Ultimately, it comes down to who offers you the best value for your money based on your specific financial needs.